Facing assault charges in Texas can be a frightening experience, especially if you are unsure of your rights or how to defend yourself. Assault is a serious accusation, and a conviction can result in harsh penalties. However, being charged with assault does not automatically mean you will be found guilty. In Texas, there are several defenses that can be used to challenge assault charges and potentially reduce or dismiss the charges altogether. Understanding these defenses can help you see the importance of seeking proper legal representation. At, McCarty Larson, PLLC, we are here to guide you through the legal process and help you navigate the complexities of your case.
Robin McCarty worked diligently with me to overcome a serious accusation. We collaborated together to unequivocally dismiss the charges with impunity. As is common when dealing with municipalities, this process took time and patience. Robin’s team was communicative, responsive and thoughtful while handling this intense situation. I highly recommend giving McCarty-Larson the opportunity to work through your case.
- Pablo Valdes
They help me through my divorce last year. It’s not easy mentally and physically but they had Great customer service any and every questions I had they answered my questions walk me through the whole process thank you and your team for all y’all did for me . What are you waiting for just call and see for yourself
- Aaron Herrera
From the first phone call late on a Friday afternoon to the successful out come of our legal issue, our family has had nothing but praises for the entire staff at McCarty-Larson. Always available, honest and upfront about the whole process. Mr. McCarty is an experienced and knowledgeable attorney with whom we always felt secure. And he genuinely cared about our family member. Robin and Natalie are a great team. Hayley was always very helpful too. Thank you to the entire staff and firm.
- Neil Phillips
Best in Ellis County! Daniel Morton, Amanda Nail, and the team at McCarty-Larson are incredibly responsive, ensuring quick and efficient handling of my case. Their staff was not only professional but also empathetic, guiding me through a challenging time. Despite the difficulties throughout my case, they prioritized my time, my needs, and got me a fair agreement that made everyone happy. Highly recommend for anyone navigating family legal matters.
- Jillian Bailey
Self-Defense
One of the most common defenses against assault charges is self-defense. In Texas, the law recognizes that a person has the right to defend themselves if they believe they are in immediate danger of harm. If someone attacked you or threatened your safety, you might have had no choice but to defend yourself. For this defense to work, it must be proven that you believed you were at risk of physical harm and that your actions were reasonable in response to the threat. The amount of force you used must also be in proportion to the threat you faced. For example, using deadly force to defend against a non-deadly threat may not hold up in court as a valid defense.
It is important to note that the self-defense argument only applies if you did not provoke the other person. If you were the one who initiated the confrontation, claiming self-defense may not be an option. Self-defense must be an immediate reaction to a direct threat. If you retaliated after the threat was over or if you sought revenge, this would not count as self-defense.
Defense of Others
Similar to self-defense, Texas law also allows a person to use reasonable force to defend another person from harm. If you believed that someone else was in immediate danger and you acted to protect them, this can serve as a valid defense against assault charges. The key factor in this defense is that your belief that the other person was in danger must be reasonable. If it is proven that the individual you defended was not in any real danger or that your response was excessive, this defense might not hold up in court.
Just like with self-defense, you cannot claim defense of others if you were the one who provoked the altercation. This defense also requires that the amount of force used be appropriate to the level of threat faced by the person you were defending.
Defense of Property
Texas law also allows individuals to use force to protect their property. If someone was attempting to steal or damage your property and you used force to prevent them from doing so, this can be a defense against assault charges. However, this defense only applies if the force you used was reasonable and necessary to stop the crime. For example, if someone tried to break into your car and you pushed them away, this might be considered reasonable. On the other hand, using deadly force to protect personal property may not be viewed as justified unless there were additional threats to your safety.
In some cases, the law permits the use of deadly force to protect property if the threat occurs at night, but this is a rare situation. Generally, courts expect individuals to avoid using excessive force in protecting property and to prioritize safety over possessions. As with other defenses, the situation must be evaluated carefully to determine whether the force used was appropriate.
Consent
In some cases, the alleged victim of the assault may have consented to the physical contact that led to the charges. For example, in contact sports such as boxing or football, participants agree to certain levels of physical contact that would normally be considered assault under different circumstances. If both parties consented to the activity that led to the alleged assault, this can be used as a defense.
The key to using the consent defense is proving that the other party voluntarily agreed to the physical contact. If the consent was not freely given or if it was withdrawn during the encounter, this defense may not be successful. Additionally, if the level of force used exceeded what was expected or agreed upon, the consent defense might not hold up in court.
Mistaken Identity
Another defense that can be used in assault cases is mistaken identity. If you were falsely accused of assault because the alleged victim or witnesses misidentified you, this can be a valid defense. In some cases, eyewitnesses may be mistaken, especially if the incident happened quickly or in a chaotic environment. The burden of proof is on the prosecution to demonstrate that you were the person who committed the assault. If there is reasonable doubt about your identity as the assailant, the charges may be dropped.
A strong mistaken identity defense often relies on alibis, witnesses, or evidence that places you somewhere else at the time of the alleged assault. It is important to gather as much information as possible to prove that you were not involved in the incident.
Lack of Intent
To be convicted of assault in Texas, the prosecution must prove that you intended to cause harm to the alleged victim. If your actions were accidental or if you had no intention of harming anyone, this can serve as a defense. For example, if you accidentally bumped into someone and they were injured as a result, this might not meet the legal definition of assault. Assault charges generally require that the defendant acted with intent to cause harm, so a lack of intent can be a key element in your defense.
However, this defense may not apply in all situations. If the prosecution can show that you were reckless or that your actions created a significant risk of harm to others, they may argue that intent is not necessary. In such cases, it is crucial to work with an attorney who can help demonstrate that your actions were not intentional.
Imminent Threat or Duress
In rare cases, a person may commit an assault because they were forced to do so under the threat of harm. If someone else threatened you with immediate harm unless you committed the assault, this defense may be available. The key to this defense is showing that you acted under duress and that you had no reasonable way to avoid committing the assault. For this defense to succeed, the threat you faced must have been immediate and unavoidable.
However, this defense is challenging to prove and is only used in extreme cases. The courts will carefully scrutinize the circumstances to determine whether you truly had no other options.
Alibi
An alibi defense involves proving that you were somewhere else when the alleged assault took place. If you have evidence, such as receipts, surveillance footage, or witnesses, showing that you could not have been at the scene of the crime, this can serve as a strong defense. An alibi can cast doubt on the prosecution’s case and lead to a dismissal of the charges if it is proven that you were not involved in the incident.
An alibi defense must be backed up by credible evidence, and it is important to gather all possible proof that you were not present at the time of the alleged assault. This can include witnesses who can confirm your location or other documentation that supports your claim.
Lack of Evidence
In any criminal case, the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you committed the offense. If there is insufficient evidence to support the assault charges, this can be a defense. The prosecution must provide clear evidence, such as witness testimony, physical evidence, or documentation, to establish that you committed the assault. If the evidence is weak or contradictory, your attorney may argue that the case does not meet the legal burden of proof.
Lack of evidence can be a powerful defense, especially if there are inconsistencies in witness statements or if there is no physical evidence linking you to the alleged crime. An attorney can help highlight these weaknesses in the prosecution’s case.
Facing assault charges in Texas can be overwhelming, but you do not have to go through it alone. Having a strong defense is crucial to protecting your rights and securing the best possible outcome. The team at McCarty Larson, PLLC understands the complexities of assault cases and is here to help you navigate the legal process. If you are facing charges, contact McCarty Larson, PLLC today to discuss your case and explore your defense options. Our experienced attorneys are ready to fight for your rights and provide you with the representation you deserve.