Misdemeanor theft charges in Texas, although often seen as minor offenses, can carry significant consequences that can impact various aspects of your life. Whether you have been accused of shoplifting, petty theft, or any other form of misdemeanor theft, understanding the charges and potential defenses is crucial in navigating the legal system and protecting your future. In Texas, theft becomes a misdemeanor offense when the value of the stolen property or services is below $2,500. Even though the penalties might seem less severe than those associated with felony theft, the long-term effects of a misdemeanor theft conviction can still be substantial. A conviction can lead to fines, jail time, and a criminal record that may hinder your ability to secure employment, housing, or professional licenses. This reality makes it essential to approach misdemeanor theft charges with the same seriousness as any other criminal accusation.
Understanding the nature of the charges is the first step in crafting an effective defense. Texas law defines theft as the unlawful appropriation of property with the intent to deprive the owner of it. This broad definition encompasses a wide range of actions, from shoplifting to failing to return rented property. The prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you intended to permanently deprive the owner of their property, that you acted without the owner’s consent, and that the value of the property falls within the misdemeanor range. The complexity of these elements offers various opportunities to challenge the prosecution’s case. Each of these elements must be carefully examined and contested, and the defenses that may be available will vary depending on the specifics of your case.
Legal Blog
Welcome to the McCarty-Larson Legal Blog, your go-to resource for insightful and up-to-date information on Criminal Defense and Family Law. Our blog is dedicated to providing comprehensive analysis, practical advice, and expert commentary on the most pressing legal issues you may face. Whether you are navigating the complexities of a criminal case or dealing with sensitive family law matters, our experienced attorneys offer invaluable guidance to help you understand your rights and make informed decisions. Stay informed and empowered with our latest articles, case studies, and legal updates.
One of the most common defense strategies in misdemeanor theft cases is to challenge the intent element. Intent is a critical component of a theft charge in Texas. The prosecution must demonstrate that you intended to deprive the owner of their property permanently. This can be a challenging aspect of the case for the prosecution to prove, as intent is often inferred from the circumstances surrounding the alleged theft. For instance, if you inadvertently took an item from a store without paying for it, believing it was your own, or if you intended to pay for it but became distracted and left the store without completing the purchase, these circumstances could negate the intent to steal. Demonstrating that your actions were the result of a mistake, confusion, or misunderstanding rather than a deliberate attempt to steal can be a powerful defense. Evidence such as witness testimony, surveillance footage, or proof of payment or return attempts can be instrumental in supporting your defense.
Another effective defense strategy in misdemeanor theft cases involves challenging the value of the stolen property or services. Since the severity of the theft charge depends on the value of the property, reducing that value to below the misdemeanor threshold or contesting the prosecution’s valuation can significantly impact the charges against you. For example, if the prosecution has overestimated the value of the property or included additional items that were not actually taken, these errors can be contested to potentially reduce the charges to a lesser offense or even result in a dismissal. An experienced attorney can work to gather evidence, such as receipts or appraisals, to challenge the prosecution’s valuation and demonstrate that the alleged theft does not meet the threshold for a misdemeanor charge.
The lack of sufficient evidence is another defense strategy that can be employed in misdemeanor theft cases. The burden of proof in a criminal case rests with the prosecution, and they must prove every element of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt. This means that if there is any doubt about your intent, the ownership of the property, or whether a theft actually occurred, these doubts can be used to challenge the prosecution’s case. For instance, if the property in question was never found in your possession, or if there is conflicting testimony about whether you actually took the property, these inconsistencies can be exploited to weaken the prosecution’s case. In some cases, the evidence may be circumstantial or based on unreliable witness accounts. By scrutinizing the evidence presented and raising doubts about its credibility, your defense attorney can create reasonable doubt in the minds of the judge or jury, potentially leading to an acquittal.
Another approach to defending against misdemeanor theft charges in Texas is to assert a claim of right or ownership. This defense applies in situations where you believed in good faith that you had a legal right to the property in question. If you genuinely believed that the property was yours or that you had permission to take or use it, this belief can negate the intent required for a theft conviction. For example, if you took an item that you thought was abandoned or believed that you had permission to use someone else’s property, this misunderstanding could form the basis of a claim of right defense. Your attorney would need to present evidence that supports your belief and demonstrate that this belief was reasonable under the circumstances. This defense can be particularly effective if there is a history of shared use or ownership of the property, or if there were communications or agreements that could have led to a reasonable misunderstanding.
Robin McCarty worked diligently with me to overcome a serious accusation. We collaborated together to unequivocally dismiss the charges with impunity. As is common when dealing with municipalities, this process took time and patience. Robin’s team was communicative, responsive and thoughtful while handling this intense situation. I highly recommend giving McCarty-Larson the opportunity to work through your case.
- Pablo Valdes
They help me through my divorce last year. It’s not easy mentally and physically but they had Great customer service any and every questions I had they answered my questions walk me through the whole process thank you and your team for all y’all did for me . What are you waiting for just call and see for yourself
- Aaron Herrera
From the first phone call late on a Friday afternoon to the successful out come of our legal issue, our family has had nothing but praises for the entire staff at McCarty-Larson. Always available, honest and upfront about the whole process. Mr. McCarty is an experienced and knowledgeable attorney with whom we always felt secure. And he genuinely cared about our family member. Robin and Natalie are a great team. Hayley was always very helpful too. Thank you to the entire staff and firm.
- Neil Phillips
Best in Ellis County! Daniel Morton, Amanda Nail, and the team at McCarty-Larson are incredibly responsive, ensuring quick and efficient handling of my case. Their staff was not only professional but also empathetic, guiding me through a challenging time. Despite the difficulties throughout my case, they prioritized my time, my needs, and got me a fair agreement that made everyone happy. Highly recommend for anyone navigating family legal matters.
- Jillian Bailey
In some cases, a defense strategy may involve demonstrating that you were the victim of entrapment. Entrapment occurs when law enforcement officers or their agents induce a person to commit a crime that they would not have otherwise committed. If you can show that the idea of committing the theft originated with someone else, particularly someone working with law enforcement, and that you were persuaded or coerced into committing the act, you may be able to argue that you were entrapped. This defense is particularly relevant in cases involving sting operations or situations where undercover officers or informants are involved. To successfully assert an entrapment defense, it must be shown that you were not predisposed to commit the theft and that the government’s actions were the primary cause of the alleged crime.
Another significant consideration in misdemeanor theft cases is the possibility of negotiating a plea deal. While not technically a defense strategy, plea bargaining can be an effective way to resolve a case without the risk of a trial. In a plea deal, you may agree to plead guilty to a lesser charge or to the misdemeanor theft charge in exchange for a reduced sentence or other favorable terms. This might include reduced fines, probation instead of jail time, or participation in a theft diversion program. Plea bargaining can be especially advantageous if the evidence against you is strong or if you want to avoid the uncertainty and publicity of a trial. However, it is important to weigh the long-term consequences of a plea deal, including the impact of a criminal record, before making a decision. An experienced attorney can help you evaluate your options and negotiate the best possible terms.
When facing misdemeanor theft charges in Texas, it is also important to consider the possibility of a pretrial diversion program. These programs are designed to offer first-time offenders the opportunity to avoid a criminal conviction by completing certain requirements, such as community service, restitution to the victim, or attending theft prevention classes. Successfully completing a diversion program can result in the dismissal of the charges and the sealing of your criminal record, allowing you to move forward without the stigma of a conviction. However, eligibility for diversion programs varies by jurisdiction, and participation often requires the approval of the prosecutor and the court. If you are eligible, your attorney can assist in applying for the program and ensuring that you meet all the requirements to successfully complete it.
Another potential defense strategy in misdemeanor theft cases is to demonstrate that the theft was committed under duress. If you were forced to commit the theft because you were threatened with harm or coerced by someone else, this could form the basis of a duress defense. To successfully assert this defense, it must be shown that the threat was imminent, that you had no reasonable opportunity to escape or avoid the threat, and that the force or threat used was sufficient to overcome your will. While this defense can be difficult to prove, especially if there is no evidence of the threat or coercion, it can be a viable option in cases where you were placed in a situation where you felt you had no other choice but to comply with the demands of the person making the threat.
The circumstances surrounding the alleged theft can also be a critical factor in your defense. For example, if you were intoxicated at the time of the alleged theft and unable to form the intent necessary for a theft conviction, this could be a viable defense. While voluntary intoxication is generally not a defense to criminal charges, it can be relevant in cases where the intoxication was so severe that it prevented you from understanding the nature of your actions. Similarly, if you were suffering from a mental illness or other condition that impaired your ability to understand or control your actions, this could also be a factor in your defense. In such cases, a psychological evaluation and testimony from medical professionals may be necessary to support your defense.
Navigating misdemeanor theft charges in Texas requires a strategic approach that considers all the factors involved in the case. With the potential consequences of a conviction, including fines, jail time, and a lasting criminal record, it is crucial to take these charges seriously and to seek the guidance of a knowledgeable defense attorney. At McCarty Larson, PLLC, our team is dedicated to providing comprehensive legal representation to individuals facing misdemeanor theft charges. We understand the complexities of these cases and are committed to protecting your rights and achieving the best possible outcome. Whether through negotiation, defense strategy, or trial, we will work tirelessly on your behalf. If you are facing misdemeanor theft charges in Texas, contact McCarty Larson, PLLC today to discuss your case and explore your options for defense.